Ever since I first laid eyes on Kenji's beef barbacoa recipe, it’s been haunting my dreams like an uninvited food ghost. Between my day job and endless grilling experiments, I kept pushing it aside—until one day in 2025, I thought, 'Why not take this baby outdoors and swap beef for lamb?' Man, what a game-changer! The result? A flavor bomb that’s smoky, spicy, and downright addictive. It’s like the lamb shoulder was this grumpy old uncle who just needed some TLC to turn into a tender superstar. And let me tell ya, the wait was worth it—this dish stole the show at my backyard bash last weekend, beating out my trusty skirt steak like it was nothing. 😋

Why Lamb Shoulder is the Real MVP

In my quest for barbacoa nirvana, I ditched beef and went for lamb shoulder—a cut that’s basically the lazy couch potato of meats. It’s packed with fat and sinew, making it perfect for low-and-slow cooking. If you try roasting it hot, it’ll fight back like a stubborn mule, but give it time in the smoker, and it transforms into melt-in-your-mouth magic. The key here is patience; this isn't a sprint, it's a marathon. And folks, in 2025, lamb is still king for rich, meaty flavors that balance smokiness and spice without overwhelming your taste buds.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__recipes__20131011-269403-lamb-barbacoa-step-1-940025d62843432b820e44ff75760202.jpg)

The Smoking and Braising Ballet

Now, for the fun part: I started with a killer rub that’s like a warm hug for the lamb. Here’s the lowdown on what I used:

• Spice Rub Ingredients (scaled down from Kenji's original):

• 2 tbsp kosher salt

• 1 tbsp each ancho and guajillo chile powder

• 1 tbsp ground cumin

• 2 tsp dried oregano (Mexican style, please!)

• 2 tsp each onion and garlic powder

• 1 tsp chipotle chile powder

• 1/4 tsp ground cloves

Slathering that on a 5-pound boneless lamb shoulder felt like dressing up a rockstar—it was ready to hit the stage. Then, into the smoker it went with oak wood chunks for three hours. Oh, the aromas! The meat soaked up that smoke like a thirsty camel, adding layers of earthy goodness. But here’s the twist: I didn’t stop there. After smoking, I transferred it to a Dutch oven, drowned it in sauce (more on that below), and braised it at 250°F for another three hours. Darn, that slow dance of heat made the lamb so tender, my probe thermometer slid in like butter.

People Also Ask: Can I skip the smoker if I don’t have one? Absolutely—just use a grill or oven, but you’ll miss out on that smoky charm. And how long does it take? Total about 6 hours, but trust me, it’s a breeze once you start.

Sauce Magic and the Overnight Miracle

While the lamb was puffing away in the smoker, I whipped up the sauce. This ain’t your average gravy—it’s a complex beast with dried chiles, cumin, cloves, and a kick from chipotles in adobo. I tweaked Kenji’s version by using guajillo chiles (what I had handy) and scaling back since the rub already packed a punch. The sauce bubbled up, infusing the lamb during braising, but the real secret? Letting it chill overnight in the sauce. That’s right—I gave the meat a spa day! Pulling it cold the next day was a breeze; I discarded any tough bits, and when reheated, it turned into tender shreds that practically sang. A final squirt of lime juice perked it up, making it fresher than a spring morning.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__images__2013__10__20131011-269403-lamb-barbacoa-pulled-69cefa9017004fdca4b9403a10f276af.jpg)

Serving Up the Flavor Fiesta

Come serving time, I piled the lamb into grill-toasted corn tortillas with onions, cilantro, and tomatillo salsa—the tartness cut through the richness like a knife. The flavor? Insanely good! That earthy, spicy sauce held hands with the lamb’s boldness, creating a harmony that had my guests raving. It was so tender, some pieces fell apart in surrender, while others stood proud. Here’s a quick guide to the perfect plate-up:

People Also Ask: What sides pair best? Try a simple slaw or grilled veggies. And can I freeze leftovers? Heck yeah—it tastes even better reheated!

A Personal Peek into the Future

As I sit here in 2025, munching on leftovers, I can’t help but dream big. Next year, I’m eyeing wild boar or even venison for this recipe—imagine the gamey notes dancing with those spices! Maybe add some exotic twists like saffron or smoked paprika from my travels. The possibilities are endless, and with climate-smart cooking on the rise, sourcing sustainable lamb is easier than ever. Who knows? Barbacoa might just become my signature dish for global food fests. 😊

So, if you’re craving a backyard adventure, give this lamb barbacoa a whirl. It’s a journey worth taking—slow, smoky, and soul-satisfying. And remember, good things come to those who wait... and braise!